S	M	T	W	T	F	S
						1
2	3	4	5	6	7	8
9	10	11	12	13	14	15
16	17	18	19	20	21	22
23	24	25	26	27	28	29
30

I'm not sure if it's even possible to call this a rec list as I'm really not all that picky about what I read. So, if I've read a story, it'll probably wind up here. Unless it was hard for me to get through for some reason (e.g. songfic, experimental style that leaves me confused, crazy grammar). So this isn't really a recs list, but it's not a master list either, since I'm a little selective. Whatever this is, hopefully someone will find it useful!

<1,000 words

As if No One is Watching by mithrel aka mithrel

Rating: PG | Word Count: 959 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Schmoop

Summary: When the disorientation of transport cleared, Sam looked around in mounting horror. “Oh, hell no!”

Reccer's Notes: Lucifer woos Sam through dance. What's not to like?
Best Idea Ever by entanglednow aka entangled_now

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: 751 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Drugs

Summary: In which Sam is made compliant in the hopes that it will make him say yes.

Reccer's Notes: I am firmly convinced that angels wouldn't be such dicks if only they were hugged more. This story supports my theory.

Podfic recorded by eosrose
Better That We Break by mithrel

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: 528 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Established Relationship, Hurt/Comfort, Wing Kink

Summary: “You don’t know what you’re asking!”

Reccer's Notes: I think it's a requirement that everyone try writing Lucifer/Sam wing!fic. I'm not complaining.
Broken Thread by emeraldembers aka emerald_embers

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: 888 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Dream Stalking, Mentions of Torture in Hell

Summary: Lucifer had not been imprisoned in one form alone.

Reccer's Notes: I'm not sure I understand what's happening here, but I like it anyway. The words carry a great deal of intensity and emotion.
Cry Me a River by holydread

Rating: R | Word Count: 658 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Established Relationship, Rough Sex

Summary: Lucifer wants to know: does Sam Winchester cry his way through sex?

Reccer's Notes: Brilliant! Just brilliant!
Eyes Forward by _bluebells

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: 670 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Dream Stalking

Summary: Sam's dream takes them to university for a change of scenery.

Reccer's Notes: I love how kind Lucifer is. It's his ability to be kind that is his greatest asset.
Frostbite by amor_remanet

Rating: PG | Word Count: ~770 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Angst, Hurt/Comfort, Dream Stalking

Summary: Lucifer visits Sam's dreams.

Reccer's Notes: Following the events of "My Bloody Valentine", Lucifer attempts to convince Sam that he's not someone Sam needs to fear. Gorgeously done.
Fundamental Disconnect by aeon_entwined

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: 954 | Timeline: Post-Cage | Warnings: Crack, Schmoop

Summary: In which the Apocalypse has ended, but the universe still apparently has its sights set on making Sam’s life into a soap opera.

Reccer's Notes: Dean's teasing leads to Sam explaining the concept of inneundo leads to Sam and Lucifer giving Dean an eyeful. Verdict? Yay!
In the Looking Glass by pickledwarf

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: 558 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Masturbation, Sam as Vessel, Exhibitionism/Voyeurism

Summary: It’s strange, how different bodies have different sensory inputs, different ways of seeing the world.

Reccer's Notes: Smut and nothing but.
Kiss 13 (50 First Kisses) by gedry

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: ~570 | Timeline: AU | Warnings: High School, Homophobia

Summary: Written for 50 first kisses – First Time.

Reccer's Notes: High School AU. Sam has never kissed anyone before. Lucifer has never had anyone defend him before. Today is a day for firsts. Very cute. There's not a lot of detail about the setting or Sam and Lucifer's histories, but I like filling in the blanks.
Kiss 39 (50 First Kisses) by gedry

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: ~530 | Timeline: AU | Warnings: Foster Brothers, High School

Summary: Written for 50 first kisses – Forgiveness.

Reccer's Notes: High School AU. Sam and Dean are fostered with Chuck Novak and his sons, Castiel, Gabriel and Lucifer.
Last Man Standing by entropy_maximum

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: 819 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Consent Issues, Dream Stalking, Established Relationship, Orgasm Denial, PWP

Summary: "Sam thinks he's gonna go insane, that or say yes and at the moment he's not sure which would be worse."

Reccer's Notes: A favorite of mine. Read it and you'll know why!
Lies and Crooked Wings [members-only] by pada_something

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: 342 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Angst, Dream Stalking

Summary: Why Sam will say yes.

Reccer's Notes: Short, but poignant.
Love Letters by xarixian

Rating: R | Word Count: 488 | Timeline: AU | Warnings: Exhibitionism/Voyeurism, Stalking

Summary: Lucifer is Sam's stalker. Sam would call the police, but he's not sure if he'd have to explain he's been jerking off to the notes. [prompt]

Reccer's Notes: Sam is so fucked up. I love it!
Time 26 (50 First Times) by gedry

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: ~650 | Timeline: AU | Warnings: Grief/Mourning, PWP

Summary: Written for 50 first times – First time after Jessica.

Reccer's Notes: What starts as a nameless, sex-only affair intended only to satisfy physical need gradually becomes something more. An interesting take on coping with grief.
What You Need by _bluebells

Rating: G | Word Count: 302 | Timeline: AU | Warnings: Crack, Dialogue Only

Summary: Lucifer tries different faces, but Sam hates them all.

Reccer's Notes: Poor, poor Sam. So long suffering!
[Untitled] by metaallu

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: 359 | Timeline: AU | Warnings: Established Relationship, Partner Betrayal, PWP, Student/Teacher, University

Summary: Lucifer is a college professor; Sam is his student. Lucifer fucks Sam over his desk! [prompt]

Reccer's Notes: Porn and nothing but the porn!

1,000-5,000 words

30 Seconds to Wake Up by slippery_fish

Rating: R | Word Count: 3,293 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Grief/Mourning

Summary: "I want my brother back," Lucifer says, and Sam shrugs.
Spoilers up to 5x19, goes AU after but uses knowledge of later episodes.

Reccer's Notes: As Lucifer struggles with his grief over Gabriel's death, he and Sam grow closer. It all unfolds beautifully. The pacing is slow, easy and absolutely perfect.
A Priori by obstinatrix

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: 1,294 | Timeline: AU | Warnings: Alpha/Beta/Omega Dynamics, Established Relationship, Possessive Behavior, Suggested Incest

Summary: Super toppy alpha Lucifer does not like the fact that Sam has another alpha's scent all over him. Doesn't matter that it's Sam's brother's scent, Lucifer will not abide. [prompt]

Reccer's Notes: Um, guh. This hits so many of my kinks it's not even funny.
And Again I See by brokenangel6662

Rating: PG | Word Count: 1,328 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Angst, Outsider's POV

Summary: Sam hasn’t said yes, but Lucifer has him. Another angel watches and sees the same patterns from an eternity ago.

Reccer's Notes: This is a beautiful glimpse of Lucifer through the eyes of another fallen angel--one who remembers him as he was and loves him still. It's nice to see Lucifer's softer side as he struggles with his conflicting desires.
Break, Fill, Overflow by entanglednow aka entangled_now

Rating: R | Word Count: 1,759 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Established Relationship, Wing Kink

Summary: Sometimes it's not about what you can see.

Reccer's Notes: Sam has a moment uncertainty; Lucifer washes away Sam's fears.
Devil's Advocate by obstinatrix

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: ~4,743 | Timeline: AU | Warnings: Boss/Employee, Power Disparity, PWP

Summary: Sam had been a junior associate at Garrison for less than a week before its senior partner decided there was an additional function he wanted him to perform.

Reccer's Notes: The seduction is hot, the sex is hot, but what really gets me is how Lucifer's interest in Sam seems to run deeper than he admits to. What can I say, I like a hint of fluff with my porn!
Fade to Black by aeon_entwined

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: ~1,200 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Bonding (Implied), Demon Blood, Wing Kink

Summary: In which Sam finds another way…

Reccer's Notes: The shift comes a little quickly and leaves me feeling a bit like I missed something, but I get the feeling that this was the author's intent. The sex is smoking hot.
Fill Me Up by checkthemargins

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: 1,913 | Timeline: AU | Warnings: First Time, Power Disparity, PWP, Student/Teacher, University, Virginity Kink

Summary: Lucifer is a college professor; Sam is his student. Lucifer fucks Sam over his desk! [prompt]

Reccer's Notes: Porn and nothing but the porn!
Fire by yellowwolf5

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: 1,324 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: PWP

Summary: Sam is drawn to Lucifer.

Reccer's Notes: Plot? What plot?
Fire Beneath by entangled_now

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: 1,005 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Angst, Established Relationship

Summary: Lucifer's time is running out.

Reccer's Notes: Lucifer's vessel is burning up; soon he'll be trapped in hell once more. Sam's desperation is palpable.
Give You Everything by cassandra_leeds

Rating: R | Word Count: 1,959 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Angst, Consent Issues, Grief/Mourning, Hurt/Comfort, PWP

Summary: Lucifer seduces while Sam holds out against saying yes.

Reccer's Notes: I ache for Sam. He's so hurt and lonely and vulnerable—ripe for the taking.
The Greater Good + No More Than This by mithrel

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: 3,261 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Consent Issues, Dream Stalking

Summary: Lucifer makes a bargain with Sam.

Reccer's Notes: I'm not entirely comfortable with the terms of Lucifer and Sam's deal, so this was an awkward read for me. But it ended on a hopeful note!
Hold On (to Yourself This Time) by aeon_entwined

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: ~1,100 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Pre-Relationship, Sam as Vessel

Summary: In which the Fate of the world rests in the hands of Sam Winchester.

Reccer's Notes: I laughed. I honestly didn't see it coming—and you're not getting anything else out of me, because I don't want to spoil it.
Idle Hands by entanglednow aka entangled_now

Rating: R | Word Count: 1,433 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Established Relationship, Masturbation, PWP, Voyeurism

Summary: Sam encourages a little exploration.

Reccer's Notes: Instant nosebleed. You won't regret reading this. Trust me.
I'll Be Your Lover by kaylynnkie

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: 1,053 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Angst, Sam as Vessel

Summary: Lucifer taunts Sam from within the depths of subconsciousness.

Reccer's Notes: An exploration of what might have been happening while Lucifer was in control during Swan Song. Beautifully done.
If I Drown Tonight, Bring Me Back to Life by aeon_entwined

Rating: R | Word Count: 1,625 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Halo Kink, PWP

Summary: In which Lucifer perfects his angelic stalking abilities and Sam discovers the King of Hell isn’t as black-and-white as he appears.

Reccer's Notes: You know. I think this might be my favorite of aeon_entwined's fics. There are lots of people writing wing!fic out there, but I don't think I've ever read halo!fic before. It hit a kink I didn't even know I had!
In Long Embrace by holydread

Rating: R | Word Count: 1,250 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Established Relationship, Possessive Behavior, PWP

Summary: Lucifer did not anticipate how long the nights would be when he threw his lot in with the Winchesters', but he is finding ways to pass the time.

Reccer's Notes: I love how tender Lucifer is toward Sam and the glimpses we're offered of how Lucifer occupies his time now that the apocalypse has been called off. ♥
Indulgence by proven_alien

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: 3,519 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: PWP, Wing Kink

Summary: "I never thought I would be free of that place, for me being trapped in the Dark, cold, alone, helpless was far worse than death, so anything you want anything and I will give it to you."

Reccer's Notes: Sam meets Lucifer in the rain … and he can't help but want. The story could use a little editing, but I like the mood and imagery of it.
It's the Soundtrack to the End by cocoaphonic + This Rhythm that Tears a Hole by free_pirate

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: 1,933 | Timeline: Season 5 (5.04) | Other Ships: Dean/Sam | Warnings: Angst, Dream Stalking

Summary: In the end, it's so easy to say yes.

Reccer's Notes: What if Sam and Dean hadn't reunited?
kiss my eyes and lay me to sleep by minviendha

Rating: R | Word Count: 4,300 | Timeline: Post-Cage | Warnings: Amnesia, Consent Issues, Psychological Horror

Summary: Sam's supposed to be lucky. He doesn't really feel it until Nick starts paying attention to him, though. AU from somewhere in S6. [prompt]

Reccer's Notes: Sam returns from the Cage with amnesia. Lucifer takes advantage in the most creepy way imaginable. The love story would almost be sweet if only we, the readers, didn't know that "Nick" is after things Sam ordinarily wouldn't want to give. Honestly, this is so creepy that it's one of my absolute favorite stories.
Lay Your Head on the Block by mithrel

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: 3,375 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Collars, Dream Stalking, First Time

Summary: Lucifer wants to get Sam to trust him any way he can.

Reccer's Notes: Big gestures go a long way.
Learn to Fly by devilsduplicity

Rating: PG | Word Count: ~1,500 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Angst, Cuddling, First Time, Schmoop

Summary: Lucifer holds Sam hostage at a strange hotel. It's not as bad as Sam thinks.

Reccer's Notes: Possibly one of the sweetest stories this particular subset of fandom has yet produced.

Podfic recorded by eosrose
[Untitled] by catboatventure aka alicat713

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: 3,050 | Timeline: AU | Warnings: Middle School, High School, Homophobia, Murder, Underage

Summary: Sam has been able to see and talk to ghosts all his life. "Lucifer" (Sam's looked him up his real name is Nick) is the troubled ghost companion he can't shake off no matter how hard he tries. And the fact he may not want Lucifer go is starting to freak Sam out. [prompt]

Reccer's Notes: This is a short piece, but the author manages to really capture Sam's sense of isolation and his growing dependency on Nick, who he starts to trust as a friend. It's obvious that there's a darker side to Nick, but Sam is willfully blind to it--until he's forced to face it head-on.

5,000-10,000 words

Lucifer Bound series by entanglednow aka entangled_now

Parts: 3/3 | Rating: R | Word Count: 7,978 | Timeline: Season 5 | Warnings: Bonding, Consent Issues, Sex Pollen, Slavery

Summary: In which Lucifer's minions are not going to win any 'employee of the month' awards.

Reccer's Notes: Lucifer is bound to Sam's will due to sex magic gone wrong. This makes great use of the classic Sex Pollen trope. It's not particularly romantic, but it's funny! Or at least I think so.

10,000+ words

The Fourth Wall series by entanglednow aka entangled_now

Parts: 15/15 | Rating: | Word Count: 40,339 | Timeline: Season 5 | Other Ships: Castiel/Dean | Warnings: None

Summary: In which fanfic saves the world.

Reccer's Notes: If you only ever read one Lucifer/Sam story, this one ought to be it.

Podfic (Parts 1-14) recorded by cookiemom6067
The Wings Were in the Way by gedry

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: ~68,000 | Timeline: AU | Other Ships: Castiel/Dean | Warnings: Attempted Suicide (Mentions of), First Time, Homophobia, Grief/Mourning, Mating, Wing Kink

Summary: Interspecies dating continues to be complicated. The continuation of a not so normal relationship.

Reccer's Notes: In an Alternate Universe where angels and humans live side-by-side, there is still a lot of room for misunderstandings between the two species. This story is primarily Castiel/Dean, but once Lucifer enters the story in Part 6, we begin to see Sam and Lucifer's romance play out. Enough parts are written from Sam or Lucifer's perspective that I feel comfortable recommending this as a satisfying (and delightfully domestic) Lucifer/Sam story. If you don't enjoy the Castiel/Dean ship, however, you should give this a pass.

Threesomes

Lucifer/Sam/Gabriel

Triattica by gedry

Rating: PG-13 | Word Count: 1,000 | Timeline: AU | Warnings: Established Relationship, Threesome, University

Summary: Sam’s used to being the center of the Gabriel and Lucifer sandwich.

Reccer's Notes: University AU. Sam appreciates that Lucifer and Gabriel aren't forcing him to choose between them, but wishes that they would get along better.

Lucifer/Sam/Jo

Gastonberry and the Nomelculous or Nomelculous and Gastonberry by gedry

Rating: R | Word Count: WIP | Timeline: AU | Other Ships: Castiel/Dean | Warnings: Threesome, Wing Kink

Summary: A love story in triplicate. Or how sharing can be a good thing. Then, Dean’s going to kill Sam. He hates his new officemate and it’s all his brother’s fault.

Reccer's Notes: N/A. I have not read this yet.

Lucifer/Sam/Michael

Time 4 (50 First Times) by gedry

Rating: NC-17 | Word Count: ~580 | Timeline: Post-Cage | Warnings: Threesome, PWP, Sam as Vessel

Summary: Written for 50 first times – First time.

Reccer's Notes: Michael and Lucifer are both living in Sam's head. Things get interesting.